what am I?
thoughts on defining culture and cultural appropriation
Last week I read an article about the decline of yoga studios in the states. But someone used the wording “is america’s cultural appropriation of yoga coming to an end”… which got me thinking about cultural appropriation again…
cultural appropriation: according to wikipedia, means the adoption of elements from a minority or marginalized culture by members of a dominant culture
This also got me thinking about culture in general. How do we define culture? Who does culture belong to? Coming from two different backgrounds, and growing up in another; I don’t know which cultures are mine, or better said, which ones I am allowed to (according to society) “call mine” … if any?
While thinking about how I define my culture, this story came to mind…
My mother comes from Ghana, and for many in Ghana it is really important to have a religion. Long story short, I am sitting in a bureaucratic office with my mom, when the officer asks my mother what religion she is. My mother’s response is: I grew up in a strict Muslim home, married a man that grew up in a strict Catholic home, and spend the last 20 years in a Hindu and Buddhist country, so you tell me, what I am. The officer was shocked, he couldn’t grasp the concept that my mother didn’t want to choose one religion. He kept telling her, it doesn’t matter which one you choose, you just need to choose one. He missed my mother’s point. She acknowledges all of them, she also lives by all of them, she respects all of them. She is all and none at the same time.
Thinking about my culture pushed me back to that room. Me sitting in that room and smiling at my mother in awe.
When my parents were younger, religion was such a big part of culture. Back in the day, my mother’s family did not want my mother marrying a man that was Roman Catholic. Back in the day my father’s family was shocked to hear that my father wanted to marry a Muslim. In other words, the people around them said: We do not want to adopt things from another culture. We need to stick to our own, since ours is the right one. This culture of “us” and “them” created separation for my parents. Instead of listening to others they “ran away”, drove off to Kenya and chose to listen to themselves, and they married. With that, they taught us the importance of choosing the things we love.
Spending my childhood in Nepal, shaped me in so many ways. It is such a big part of who I am. But I am not Nepali, yet I “take” from their culture. Is this ok? Is it ok because people define me as a person of color? Or in order for me to take, do I need to disclaim that I grew up there? I do yoga, I meditate. These two belong to my daily practices, and I create time and I create space for them daily. Maybe at some point, I will make money from this. Is this ok? I have a high reverence for these practices. Am I allowed to sit in front of a group of people and guide a meditation practice that originates from South East Asia? Or am I only allowed to learn a meditation practice from a dominant culture to be able to guide it?
Dominant. I don’t like that word. What is a dominant culture? Are we giving the dominant culture more dominance because we acknowledge them as the dominant culture? In a weird way, do our labels create a hierarchy? If dominance is strength, then how can one culture be stronger than another?
“the cultural appropriation of yoga coming to an end”… If people stop adopting things from other cultures, where will this lead? I am exaggerating now, but if I think of clothes: my mother is allowed to wear Ghanian clothing. Am I allowed to wear Ghanian clothing? I am Brown. Are my children allowed to wear Ghanian clothing? They are white. Or if they wear Ghanian clothing, do they need to inform people that they are Ghanian in order for this to be ok? Does this cause unity? or uniformity? Are we striving for uniformity? Striving for uniformity in polarity? In us versus them, my culture is mine and yours is yours? If my children wear Ghanian clothing with reverence, are they the problem? If I teach Yoga with reverence, am I the problem?
All of this is confusing me. So much that sometimes I feel like I am not allowed to define myself. I need to put myself aside, and let others define what culture I am part of, and with that, what I am allowed to do. Maybe it would be easier for me to understand appropriation if I knew exactly which group I belonged to. So is culture how we define ourselves? Is it where we lived the longest? Is it what we look like? Is it where our parents come from? whose rules do I need to live by to be accepted? Which culture do I need to choose? Just like my mother said sitting in the bureaucratic office in Ghana,
you tell me what I am….
What
am
I?
These love letters will always be free. If you’d like to support them (or me), you can buy me a coffee or become a supporter and get the key to my heart. Just kidding: the key to my diary about building my brand.
comments